Shipowners can shield against accidents by better learning from human factors

(Posted on 31/01/25)

The University of Strathclyde in Scotland, UK is encouraging ship operators, safety professionals and accident investigators to use the Safety Human Incident & Error Learning Database (SHIELD) to better understand the underlying root cause of human-factor related issues in maritime incidents.

SHIELD, developed by a consortium of partners across the aviation and maritime spheres as part of the European Union’s SAFEMODE project, was launched in 2022 and is now being used by major cruise lines, a UK-based ferry operator, safety agencies in Europe and Asia, and a number of accident investigation boards.

But more data is required if SHIELD is to have a material benefit on future maritime safety and policy, says Dr Rafet Emek Kurt, the head of the University’s Maritime Human Factors Centre, who led the SHIELD development for maritime.

"Human factors have long been recognized as a critical element in shipping safety, yet whenever there is an accident, in reaction to the lessons learnt we continue to overload the seafarer with more safety procedures, more checklists, more training. This is largely ineffective in reducing human factor incidents and increases the cognitive load on the seafarer. We need to address the root cause of an accident to have any meaningful impact.”

Kurt said that the SHIELD platform provides invaluable feedback to shipmanagers, policymakers, accident investigators, and ship and system builders to better quantify the human components in safety risk models, resulting in positive changes in ship design, operations and rules.

“So far, in the absence of high-quality data, the maritime sector has failed to include human factor considerations in critical decision making. As a result, envisaged safety improvements from the sector have been ineffective, with accidents continuing to occur at a steady rate after.”

Dr Kurt emphasised that through industry-wide collaboration and use of SHIELD, stakeholders can better understand underlying human factor contributors. The data can also serve to develop new accident and risk models as well as tailor research to address any shortcomings.

Using an iceberg analogy, where the visible part represents human factors, and the submerged part represents underlying conditions, Kurt said it is what’s beneath the waterline that is important.

“At the tip of the iceberg, it may be relatively easy to see what happened, when it happened and who did what. But the reasons why it happened are not uncovered. SHIELD allows us to take a deeper dive,” he said.

The SHIELD taxonomy assesses input data against a range of extenuating factors affecting human performance, such as workload, situation awareness, stress and fatigue, human system interfaces, and teamwork. But it goes further by providing insight into how organisational and leadership structures, strategies, cultures and socioeconomics play a part.

“It’s an effective safety learning platform but we need more companies to upload their data to allow the maritime industry to better capture and learn from the underlying human factor-issues in incidents. By aggregating anonymized data from participants, SHIELD researchers can identify emerging trends and patterns across the industry. It also helps ship operators by helping them address and identify the major accident contributors not typically picked up in an accident investigation report.”

Insights gleaned can also directly inform the work of naval architects, equipment manufacturers, and regulators. By understanding the human factors challenges faced by operators, these stakeholders can design safer, more user-friendly systems and implement targeted policies to address systemic problems.

"SHIELD represents a paradigm shift in how the shipping industry approaches safety," said Kurt. "By empowering shipowners to deeply analyse their accident data, we can move beyond the traditional 'human error' narrative and uncover the true drivers of incidents. This knowledge is invaluable in creating a safer, more efficient, and more sustainable maritime sector."

Shipowners interested in leveraging the power of SHIELD are encouraged to contact the University of Strathclyde’s Maritime Human Factors Centre.

Latest News

NORDEN sells two additional vessels

NORDEN has announced that they have sold two additional vessels, one Supramax bulk carrier and one MR... Read more

Columbia Group backs Turkey as global shipping leader

Columbia Group CEO, Mark O’Neil, has paid tribute to Turkey’s ‘resilient and innovative... Read more

Pacific Basin signs MOU to enhance access to green fuels

Pacific Basin Shipping Limited, one of the world’s leading dry bulk shipping companies, has signed... Read more

Major milestone for nuclear-powered ships as IMO agrees outdated regulations revision

The IMO has formally agreed to start the revision of outdated regulations for nuclear-powered ships.... Read more

Unique Snapshot highlights true state of bullying and harassment

In advance of the IMO Day of the Seafarer’s focus on ‘My Harassment-Free Ship’, Sailors... Read more

Seafarers must not be made scapegoats, says InterManager

The threat of prosecution from a criminal investigation should never be held against an individual seafarer... Read more

Increase in female crews reporting sexual harassment is positive shift, says MHSS

As the industry comes together this week to celebrate Day of the Seafarer and promote the theme &lsquo... Read more

Biomar delivered to AtoB@C Shipping as production of last vessel of series begins

Biomar has been delivered to ESL Shipping's subsidiary AtoB@C Shipping on June 16, bringing the number... Read more

Smart Ship Hub digital platform deployed for Great Eastern Shipping Company fleet

Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. (GESCO), India's largest private fleet owner of bulkers and tankers,... Read more

Baltic Exchange introduces monthly audits to improve Baltic index quality

Baltic Exchange has launched a new quality control mechanism to support its ongoing audit policies for... Read more